You’re noticing drafts creeping in around your windows, maybe a little condensation between the panes, or even some worn-down spots on the frames. Maybe you’re just tired of struggling to open that one stubborn window in the living room. Either way, you’re at a crossroads and you think to yourself “Should I repair these windows or just replace them altogether?” We understand this decision isn’t easy, and the idea of replacing windows can feel overwhelming, especially when you’re just not sure what makes the most financial and practical sense. Here at 12 Penny Exteriors, your local Window Depot, we’ve walked this path with countless homeowners just like you. Our goal is to help you make an informed decision so you can keep your home cozy, efficient, and looking its best. By the end of this article, you’ll have a better sense of when repairs make sense and when a replacement is the smarter move.
Some Signs Your Windows Might Just Need Some TLC
Sometimes, it only takes a minor fix to get your windows back in shape. Here are some common issues where repairs may be a practical solution.
Minor Frame or Glass Damage
If you notice small cracks or chips in the glass or slight damage to the frame, these can often be repaired without needing a full replacement. For example: Glass Scratches: Minor scratches on glass can sometimes be buffed out, especially if they’re not compromising the window’s integrity. Glass is Cracked or Broken: If you have a more serious crack or the window is broken, often times, you can get a replacement sash from the window manufacturer or a local glass company can repair the broken glass for a fraction of the cost of replacing the entire window. Frame cracks or rot: For wooden frames, small areas of rot can be patched or repaired, and for vinyl frames, small cracks can be sealed.
Stuck or Hard-to-Open Windows
A window that is tough to open or close may just need a little adjustment. Often, “cleaning and lubricating” the tracks can make a huge difference. For older double hung windows, repairing the sash cords or balances can bring back smooth operation. Check with your window manufacturers to see if your parts are readily available.
Minor Drafts and Seal Failures
If you’re feeling a bit of a draft, it could just be an issue with the weatherstripping or caulking around the window. Reapplying caulk or replacing old weatherstripping can often seal up these gaps, making your windows more energy-efficient without a major expense.
When repair is the Right Choice:
Repairs are usually best when the windows are structurally sound, and the issues are small or isolated. If your windows are less than 10 years old and showing minimal issues, repairs may get them working like new again.
When It’s Time to Consider a Full-Replacement
While repairs can save you money, there are times when a full replacement will actually be more cost-effective and improve your home’s comfort, energy efficiency, and even its value. Here’s when a replacement might be the better option.
When Windows are 15-20 Years Old (or Older!)
Most windows have a lifespan of around 15-20 years, depending on materials and climate. And “builder grade” windows have an even shorter lifespan – about 7-10 years. If your windows are nearing or exceeding this age, they’re likely past their prime. Older windows can have deteriorated seals, fading energy efficiency, and outdated materials that struggle to hold up against harsh New England winters.
Significant Drafts or Insulation Issues
If you’re feeling substantial drafts, struggling with hot or cold spots near your windows, or dealing with rising energy bills, it might be a sign that your windows are no longer insulating as they should. Modern windows are built with better insulation, including Low-E coatings and argon or krypton gas fills, to keep your home more comfortable.
Noticeable Condensation (or Fogginess) Between Panes
If you see fogging or condensation between the panes of glass, and no matter how hard you try, it just won’t get clean, it usually means the seal is broken. On a double or triple pane window, the panes of glass are held together with a “spacer.” Manufacturers fill the area between the glass and the spacer with argon or krypton gas. If the spacer becomes loose, then the gas leaks out of the window and causes the “fogginess” on the interior of the glass.
Windows that do not operate correctly (despite efforts to lubricate or adjust)
If, despite best efforts to adjust or lubricate the windows, they cannot be opened, a replacement may be needed. When Replacement Is the Right Choice: Replacement is usually the better option when windows are old, showing severe signs of damage, or no longer performing well. New windows can significantly improve your home’s comfort and value.
Cost Comparison: Repair vs. Replace
One of the biggest considerations is the cost difference between repairing and replacing your windows. Here is how they generally stack up.
Repair Costs
Minor repairs like re-caulking or replacing weatherstripping can cost between $100 – $300 per window. If you’re handy, you may be able to do this yourself for even less of an investment. Glass replacement will cost you a bit more and could range between $200 – $500, depending on the size, shape, color, grids, etc. Frame repairs can vary significantly based on materials, accessibility, and the extent of the damage. Wood windows will cost more to repair than their vinyl counterparts.
Replacement Costs
On average, replacing a single window can range from $700 – $3,000 depending on material, glass, custom color, grids, accessibility, and a host of other factors. For example, a typical double hung replacement window with no bells and whistles will start at about $700 per window. That same window in wood or fiberglass will cost you about $1,300 per window. PRO TIP: Replacing multiple windows at once will help with some cost savings. Through economies of scale, it is less expensive per window to replace 10 windows than it would be to replace just one or two. Things like setup fees, permit and inspection fees, and trash fees can be spread out over many windows as opposed to just a few.
Energy Efficiency and Long-Term Savings
Energy efficiency is one of the biggest reasons homeowners decide to replace their windows rather than repair them. New windows with double or triple-pane glass, Low-E coatings, energy efficient gases can provide substantial savings over time. Also, with more efficient windows, your HVAC system will not work as hard, and the overall air quality of your home will improve drastically. Typically, today’s energy-efficient windows can save you between 10-25% off your energy bills every year. And with prices of oil, natural gas, and electricity always on the rise, these savings can add up over time.
Improved Home Value
Not only do new windows enhance curb appeal, but they can also increase your home’s resale value. Potential buyers see new windows as a bonus since they won’t have to worry about replacing them anytime soon. And studies show that windows can have a return on their investment of about 70-80%, especially if you’re adding modern, energy-efficient windows. Here at 12 Penny Exteriors, Inc, your local Window Depot, we can help walk you through all there is to think about when deciding between simply repairing your windows or replacing them new ones. If a simple repair is all you need, we’ll be the first to tell you. Reach out to us today, and let’s find the right path to make your home as comfortable and efficient as possible.
